Recurly vs BuildBase: the $249 you pay before the percentage starts
Recurly's Starter plan is $249 a month plus 0.9% of billing volume, with the first $40K excluded from the percentage. What that floor costs before you have revenue, and where BuildBase fits instead.
In short
Recurly's Starter plan is $249 a month plus 0.9% of billing volume, with the first $40,000 of billings excluded. Below that threshold the percentage is zero, so Starter is a flat $249 a month, or $2,988 a year, before you have revenue. BuildBase charges a flat plan price and takes no share of billings.
Recurly's pricing page gives its Starter tier a headline most comparisons repeat without reading twice: $249 per month plus 0.9% of billing volume.
Read the line under it. The first $40K of billings is included at no charge each month.
So if you bill less than $40,000 a month, Recurly's revenue share is zero. The percentage everyone argues about never fires. You are paying a flat $249 a month, $2,988 a year, and you are paying it before the first dollar of revenue shows up.
The one-paragraph answer
Recurly is a subscription management platform priced on billing volume, and the volume buys depth: 20 named payment gateways, failed-payment recovery with published recovery rates, and a revenue recognition product that handles ASC 606. BuildBase is an SDK where billing is one of 20 modules, sitting beside authentication, workspaces and role permissions, and running on your own Stripe account for a flat plan price. Pick Recurly when somebody's job description already includes recovering failed payments across several gateways and closing the books under ASC 606. Pick BuildBase when billing is the fourth system you have not built yet and Stripe is already your processor. What decides it is the floor, and what the floor buys.
Below $40,000 a month, the percentage is zero
Recurly Starter costs $249 per month plus 0.9% of billing volume, and Recurly excludes the first $40K of billings from that percentage every month. Under that threshold the share never applies, so Starter behaves as a flat fee: $249 a month, $2,988 a year, whatever you bill. At seed stage that is the number to compare, not the 0.9%.
$40,000 a month is $480,000 a year of billings. A good share of the companies shopping for a subscription platform are below it. So the thing being sold as revenue-share pricing is, for that entire cohort, a fixed-price subscription, and the fixed price is the only part of the rate card that touches them.
Key takeaway
Under $40,000 a month billed, Recurly Starter is a flat $249 a month. That is more than every BuildBase plan added together: Free $0, Launch $19, Grow $49 and Scale $99 come to $167.
Where the percentage starts to bite
The 0.9% overtakes the $249 platform fee at roughly $67,700 a month billed. Below that point the fee is the larger half of your Recurly bill; above it the percentage is, and it keeps climbing while the $249 sits still. In annual terms the crossover lands near $812,000 of billings.
The arithmetic is one line, and you can check it. 0.9% of $27,667 is $249, and the percentage applies only above the $40,000 allowance, so the fee and the share meet at $40,000 plus $27,667.
Push it out. At $100,000 a month billed, Starter is $249 plus 0.9% of $60,000, which comes to $789 a month. At $1,000,000 a month, the same arithmetic would give $8,889. You would have moved to All-Access well before then. That tier is quoted as under 1% of billing volume, billed annually, against a $1M billing volume minimum, with no published rate, so this post quotes none. We wrote the general version of this crossover in the hidden revenue tax of billing platforms, including how to find yours against any vendor's published rate.
What the rest of the finance stack costs
Revenue recognition starts at $850 a month and Engage at $1,600, both billed annually and both sold as their own products. The $249 buys subscription billing and nothing else. The two things people usually mean when they say they need Recurly are separate line items.
Put revenue recognition alongside Starter and the floor is $1,099 a month before any percentage, or $13,188 a year. Add Engage and it is $2,699 a month, $32,388 a year. Both carry an "as low as" and scale with your billing volume, so read them as floors rather than quotes.
None of that is a trick. It is how finance software has always been sold, and the products are real. But it does mean the question at signup is how much of this you need in year one, not which tier you are on. Founders get that one wrong in both directions.
Where BuildBase charges differently
BuildBase charges the flat price of the plan you are on and takes no share of your billing volume. Free at $0, then Launch at $19, Grow at $49 and Scale at $99 a month, with a seven-day trial on the paid plans and no card needed to start one. Yearly is ten months for twelve, so Scale is $990 a year. Those were current on 31 October 2026 and the live ones are always at /pricing.
Three things are metered and bill overage: workflow runs at $0.25, $0.15 and $0.10 per 1,000 on Launch, Grow and Scale, web analytics events at $2 per 100,000, and storage at $0.10 per GB-month. Every other quota is a hard allowance that stops rather than bills. Stripe's processing fees are Stripe's, charged to your own Stripe account, and nothing sits in between taking a cut.
Set the two floors side by side. Recurly's cheapest published way in is $2,988 a year. Scale, our top self-serve plan, is $990. That is roughly three times, and neither number moves when your revenue does.
What the billing module does is narrower than Recurly's platform and wider than a Stripe wrapper. Subscription plans with versioning, where existing subscribers stay on their version until you migrate them. Trials that convert without a second checkout. Seat and usage pricing, flat or in graduated or volume tiers, with overage reported to Stripe Billing Meters. Add-ons as recurring, one-time, lifetime or consumable, plus promotion codes, Stripe Tax at checkout, a credit ledger, and per-plan pricing variants across 21 currencies. Plans can be paid by a workspace or by a person, with one payer covering several workspaces, and entitlements are checked by feature rather than by plan name.
The part Recurly does not sell at any price is the rest of the application. Sign-in is 16 methods, Enterprise SSO among them, through your own WorkOS account on our Enterprise plan. Workspaces and role permissions live in that same instance and read the same user records your billing does, which is the whole reason a seat count and a role check never disagree here.
| Feature | BuildBase | Recurly |
|---|---|---|
| Published price | Free $0, then $19, $49 and $99 a month, flat; our own Enterprise tier is priced by conversation | Starter $249/mo + 0.9% of billings, first $40K excluded; All-Access under 1%, $1M volume minimum, rate by quote |
| How the bill grows | It does not grow with revenue; overage only on workflow runs, analytics events and storage | Flat below $40K billed a month, then a share of everything above it |
| Free way in | A Free plan at $0, and a 7-day trial on the paid plans | A 90-day free trial on Starter |
| Payment gateways | Stripe only, on your own Stripe account | 20 named gateways including Adyen, Braintree, GoCardless, Cybersource and dLocal |
| Local payment methods | Whatever your Stripe account supports, priced in 21 currencies | Pix Automatico, UPI AutoPay, GCash, Boleto, iDEAL, BACS, BECS and more, cards in 140+ currencies |
| Failed payment recovery | Not built: a lapse policy and Slack alerts, with whatever Stripe retries underneath | ML-timed and rule-based retries, card account updater, backup payment method, dunning campaigns per plan |
| Revenue recognition | Not built: an MRR and churn screen, no recognition, no ERP sync | Sold separately from $850/mo: ASC 606, IFRS 15, multi-book and multi-entity |
| Auth, workspaces and roles | 16 sign-in methods (Enterprise SSO through your own WorkOS account, on the Enterprise plan), multi-tenant workspaces and role permissions in the same instance | Out of scope: Recurly states it does not address end-user authentication, accounts or access control |
Where Recurly wins
Where Recurly wins
Four things, and the first two are not close.
Getting paid when the card fails. Recurly sells failed-payment recovery as a product: retries timed by a model as well as rules you set, a card account updater, a backup payment method that steps in once an invoice enters dunning, and dunning campaigns you assign per plan or per account. It publishes numbers for it too, including a 49% annual dunning recovery rate and 72% of at-risk subscribers saved. BuildBase stores a dunning state and applies a lapse policy when it runs out, and the retries themselves are Stripe's. We publish no recovery statistic because we have not measured one. If involuntary churn is a line on your board deck, that gap is the whole argument.
Closing the books. Recurly's revenue recognition product covers ASC 606 and IFRS 15, along with ASC 842 and ASC 340-40, with multi-book and multi-entity accounting, from $850 a month. BuildBase has a revenue screen showing monthly recurring revenue, churn, trial conversion and cash per currency. That is a dashboard. It syncs to no ERP, it produces no deferred revenue schedule, and the difference matters to one person exactly: the controller who owes someone one. We do not serve them.
Getting paid outside Stripe. Recurly's docs name 20 gateways, among them Adyen, Braintree, GoCardless, Cybersource, dLocal and Checkout.com, plus local rails including Pix Automatico in Brazil, UPI AutoPay in India, GCash, Boleto, iDEAL, BACS and BECS, with cards in 140+ currencies. BuildBase is Stripe and only Stripe. If you need direct debit through GoCardless, or the ability to change processor without re-platforming, we are the wrong answer and no module count fixes it.
The trial, and the proof behind it. Starter comes with a 90-day free trial, which is long enough to migrate a real subscriber base and watch a full quarter of renewals before paying anything. Recurly's own security page lists SOC 2 Type II. BuildBase is a younger product with a shorter trial on its paid plans, and we make no certification claim at all.
So which problem do you have
Ask which system breaks first, not which rate card reads lower.
If a declined card in Brazil is recoverable revenue rather than a support ticket, and somebody in your company has the word revenue in their title and a quarter-end they dread, you want a billing platform. Recurly is a serious one, and the $249 plus the percentage is buying a recovery engine and a gateway network that genuinely exist. Price it properly against Stripe Billing, Chargebee and the rest of the field in Stripe Billing alternatives.
If the honest description is "we charge a few hundred companies for seats and a plan tier on Stripe, and we also need login, and workspaces, and a way to say who can see what", then $2,988 a year is buying a gateway network you will not connect and a dunning campaign nobody will write. Metered and seat-based billing are different businesses, and the multi-vendor version of the second one is costed in the real monthly cost of Clerk plus Stripe plus Lago plus Knock.
We know the second shape because it is ours. PlugNode runs usage-based credit metering on this billing module, and BuildBase meters its own workflow runs through it, which is why the overage rates further up exist at all. That worked because the meter already knew which workspace a run belonged to, and whether the caller's role was allowed to start it. Bolt a billing platform on from outside and those two questions become glue code you write again for every product you ship. That is the trade, and the concessions above are not a courtesy.
A note on sourcing. The Starter price of $249 per month plus 0.9% of billing volume, the first $40K of billings included at no charge each month, and the 90-day free trial were read on recurly.com and verified 10 November 2026. So were All-Access at under 1% against its $1M billing volume minimum, revenue recognition from $850 a month and Engage from $1,600. The gateway list and the payment methods are docs.recurly.com the same day, and the recovery figures and the ASC 606 coverage are the product pages the same day. Recurly's All-Access rate and anything quoted by its sales team carry no public number, so this post quotes none, and it names no ERP partner because Recurly's own page names none. Every calculation here is ours, worked from Recurly's published figures and shown so you can check it. Our plan prices and overage rates come from the shared constants this site builds from, where PLAN_FACTS was verified 31 October 2026, and the live ones are always at /pricing.